Why doesn't Java autoboxing extend to method invocations of methods of the autoboxed types? *

Question

I want to convert a primitive to a string, and I tried:

myInt.toString();

This fails with the error:

int cannot be dereferenced

Now, I get that primitives are not reference types (ie, not an Object) and so cannot have methods. However, Java 5 introduced autoboxing and unboxing (a la C#... which I never liked in C#, but that's beside the point). So with autoboxing, I would expect the above to convert myInt to an Integer and then call toString() on that.

Furthermore, I believe C# allows such a call, unless I remember incorrectly. Is this just an unfortunate shortcoming of Java's autoboxing/unboxing specification, or is there a good reason for this?

Answer

Java autoboxing/unboxing doesn't go to the extent to allow you to dereference a primitive, so your compiler prevents it. Your compiler still knows myInt as a primitive. There's a paper about this issue at jcp.org.

Autoboxing is mainly useful during assignment or parameter passing -- allowing you to pass a primitive as an object (or vice versa), or assign a primitive to an object (or vice versa).

So unfortunately, you would have to do it like this: (kudos Patrick, I switched to your way)

Integer.toString(myInt);

< br > via < a class="StackLink" href=" http://stackoverflow.com/questions/4242/" >Why doesn't Java autoboxing extend to method invocations of methods of the autoboxed types?< /a>

Share on Google Plus

About Cinema Guy

This is a short description in the author block about the author. You edit it by entering text in the "Biographical Info" field in the user admin panel.